1. Original Sin part 60, Truth, part 4
Last week, I discussed how humans mischaracterize nonhumans because supposed
human superiority is needed to justify the harmful exploitation of animals.
If humans merely performed better on certain mental tests, this would no
more justify abusing animals than it would justify abusing humans who have
reduced cognitive skills. It is crucial for the abusers to claim that humans
are morally superior to nonhumans. This conviction is both dubious and
dangerous.
Many nonhumans display altruism. Nearly everyone who shares their lives with
dogs can give examples. Among many other examples,
rhesus monkeys
frequently refused to eat when they recognized that their taking food
resulted in a painful electric shock to a fellow rhesus monkey, and
rats can be altruistic.
While everyone acknowledges human frailties, people frequently assert that
human moral superiority justifies animal exploitation and abuse. The
hypocrisy of this position – that moral superiority justifies immoral
behavior – appears to be lost on nearly everyone except animal advocates.
Moreover, belief in our general moral goodness can make us blind to our
capacity to join the scapegoating mob and participate in violence. This has
happened repeatedly throughout history, including in Nazi Germany, perhaps
the world’s most educated nation at the time. The most effective way to
avoid the temptation to participate in scapegoating process is to recognize
our capacity for evil. Only then might we recognize that what appears to be
true and good is actually unjust victimization.
Therefore, if we are to address the original sin of participating in
scapegoating, we must recognize our capacity for evil. As long as people try
to justify exploitation of animals on the grounds of human superiority,
humans will continue to abuse both humans and nonhumans. Humanity continues
to manifest original sin – the consequences of which now threaten the
viability of human civilization – by choice.
Stephen R. Kaufman, M.D.
2. David Clough - On Animals II: Theological Ethics on Tour
During February 2019, David Clough is touring North America, speaking at
20 universities, seminaries, and churches. Check the list below to find the
one closest to you. The events provide a unique opportunity to hear about
his new work On Animals Vol. 2: Theological Ethics first-hand. Both this
volume and On Animals Vol. 1: Systematic Theology have been praised highly
by leading academicians.
If you can’t get to one of the events, but would be interested in hosting a
virtual lecture at your institution or church, contact
Creature Kind.
Details for each event will be posted on the
Events page as they
become available.
1/30/2019
11:30 am–12:00 pm (ET)
Yale Divinity School Chapel
New Haven, CT
1/31/2019
12:15–1:15 pm (ET)
Boston University School of Theology
Boston, MA
2/1/2019
12:00 pm–1:00 pm (ET)
Harvard Law School
Cambridge, MA
2/3/2019
10:10 am (ET)
Christ Episcopal Church
Rockville, MD
2/4/2019
12:00 pm (ET)
Lunch Talk & 7:00 pm (ET)
Georgetown University Washington, DC
2/5/2019
12:00 pm–1:30 pm (ET)
Wesley Theological Seminary
Washington, DC
2/6/2019
4:00 pm (ET)
University of Virginia
Charlottesville, VA
2/7/2019
4:30 pm (ET)
High Point University
High Point, NC
2/8/2019
Evening Lecture
Duke Divinity School
Durham, NC
2/11/2019
4:00 pm (CT)
Wheaton College
Wheaton, IL
2/12/2019
11:45 am–12:15 pm (CT)
Chapel Presentation
Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary
Elkhart, IN
2/12/2019
5:15 pm (CT)
University of Notre Dame
South Bend, IN
2/14/2019
12:00 pm (PT)
Santa Clara University
Santa Clara, CA
2/18/2019
3:00 pm–5:00 pm (PT)
Fuller Theological Seminary
Los Angeles, CA
2/19/2018
6:00 pm (PT)
Azusa Pacific University
Los Angeles, CA
2/25/2019
7:30 pm–9:00 pm (PT)
Regent College
Vancouver, British Columbia
2/26/2019
7:00 pm (PT)
Vancouver Central Library
Vancouver, British Columbia
2/27/2019
11:00 am–12:00 pm (PT)
University of Victoria
Victoria, British Columbia
3. All-Creatures.Org Ministry