A Condescending Carnivore
Paul Hansen, a CVA sustaining member, wrote this letter to us
recently and I believe many of us might share some if his feeling and
thoughts.
“Sometimes we vegetarians are accused—and guilty—of assuming the
moral high ground and looking down upon our unenlightened, meat-eating
friends. Of course, if we believe our food choices are intrinsically
superior because of ethical, economic (land-use), environmental, and
health reasons, it is hard to do otherwise. But I suspect some of us at
least restrain ourselves by silently thinking "Father, forgive them, for
they know not what they do." Ignorance may or may not be excusable,
depending on your tolerance level.
However, recently I was appalled at the blatant, in-your-face
attitude of one particular restaurant owner, whose popular menu catered
to mainstream American carnivores. While on vacation, some relatives of
mine suggested we have a family reunion supper at "Famous Dave's
Barbecue" in Minnetonka, Minnesota. After being seated, I soon noticed
that all the waiters and waitresses were wearing black T-shirts with
various inscriptions on their backs in white lettering. One read "WE DIG
PIG". Another read "GET YOUR MEAT ON". Another read "WE WILL SERVE NO
SWINE UNTIL IT'S TIME". Still others read "A RIB A DAY KEEPS THE VEGANS
AWAY" or "A PIG A DAY KEEPS THE VEGANS AWAY." There may have been others
I missed.
As I sat there trying to gage my own response, I couldn't help
wondering what all those customers would say and do if they watched a
few undercover videos taken at factory farms by PETA or the Human
Farming Association. Many of them attend church on Sundays and sing the
doxology, "Praise God ALL CREATURES here below", as well as other hymns
that affirm the value of all life. Juxtaposing such words on the screen
with images of animal cruelty done just to maximize profit would, I
think, be a powerful way to show the incongruity of meat industry
practices with genuine animal care. Some of the abuse is so repulsive it
should be a turn-off even to those who lack a religious perspective.
Thankfully, many faith-based groups like CVA are paying more than
mere lip service to the principle that "animal cruelty ought to be
avoided." Sadly, however, most conservative churches have yet to see the
moral "disconnect" between that principle and their food choices, which
support an industry that reduces sentient mammals to the stature of mere
material to be processed in the most efficient manner possible.
Overturning centuries of culinary custom—much like ending the annual
Canadian slaughter of harp seals or the illegal poaching of tigers,
bears, and elephants—may require nothing short of a cultural revolution.
And that revolution, if it ever comes, will be accelerated by the
continuing efforts of groups like PETA and CVA to inform people about
the sort of lives animals lead from birth to their arrival in neat,
cellophane packages in supermarkets. Factory farms want the public to
remain ignorant of "what goes on in there." It's time for the church to
come out of the "dark ages", to re-evaluate the relation of humans to
animals, and to shine a light on practices that subvert God's intention
for creatures on this planet.
Keep up the good work!.
Your question and comments are welcome
