The bottom line is that racehorse trainers who resort to using a tongue-tie do so with the aim of boosting performance. For the vast majority of horses a tongue-tie is an unnecessary and distressing intrusion.
Preparing horse for a tongue tie to be applied: a practice outlawed
in Germany in 2018. (Vince Caligiuri)
Tongue-ties are banned in most non-racing sports by the
international governing body of equestrian sports, Federation
Equestre Internationale, so you will not see them in events like
show-jumping, dressage and eventing.
Tongue-ties are used in horse racing around the world in varying
degrees, and require no veterinary oversight.
A tongue-tie is a large elastic band or nylon stocking that is
tightly wrapped around a horse’s tongue and then tied around the
lower jaw to keep the tongue in place during training or racing.
The little-known or overlooked use of the tongue-tie is accomplished
by a trainer or someone similar firmly grabbing hold of a horse’s
tongue and twisting a tie, usually made of nylon stocking, leather
or elastic, around the base of a horse’s tongue in a figure of
eight, then pulling or tying the band over the bottom jaw to hold
the tongue in place.
Over 20% of Australian horses race with their tongues tied to
their lower jaw reports The Conversation.
A tongue-tie results in horses showing signs of pain, anxiety,
distress, difficulty swallowing, cuts and lacerations to the tongue,
and bruising and swelling. The restriction of blood flow by
tongue-tie use can cause the tongue to turn blue and result in
permanent tissue damage — and for what?
The main justification for using a tongue-tie is to prevent
‘choking’ or the horse’s airway from being obstructed by soft tissue
at the back of the horse’s mouth. Research shows that while
tongue-ties may assist a small proportion of horses, how a
tongue-tie actually achieves this outcome is unclear. In actuality
there is no evidence that tongue-ties have any respiratory benefit
in healthy horses.
Horses and jockeys charge down the track at Los Alamitos (Luis
Sinco / Los Angeles Times). In this image you can see that three out
of the four racehorses pictured are fitted with tongue-ties.
The bottom line is that racehorse trainers who resort to using a
tongue-tie do so with the aim of boosting performance. Yet there is
virtually no proof this is ever achieved either. For the vast
majority of horses a tongue-tie is an unnecessary and distressing
intrusion.
Our question is this? If a horse has issues so he has trouble
breathing while exerting himself at race speeds no matter what the
reason, should that horse be racing?
New Zealand researchers state that the tack we use and the way we
ride can affect not only a horse’s capacity for breathing but also
his feelings of breathlessness, which in turn can compromise his
health, performance, and welfare.
We see no beneficial purpose or using a tongue-tie on a horse and
call a ban for its use in both equine training and competition
including horse racing. There is precedence for this.
In 2018 Germany banned the use of the tongue-tie in horse racing
amid animal welfare concerns. Their use was already forbidden in
other equestrian sports in the country before it was applied to
horse racing.
“With growing animal welfare activities, especially in Germany,
there was no possibility of allowing the use of tongue-ties to
continue,” stated Rüdiger Schmanns, director of German Racing.
The British Horse Racing Board was approached to do the same shortly
thereafter but they stated they saw no need for such a ban.
“Tongue ties have been discussed on a number of occasions by our
veterinary committee and meetings of our team of veterinary
officers, but no proposal to ban them has ever been carried forward
from either of those groups,” responded a BHA spokesman at the time.
No surprise there. We imagine US racing will be equally unreceptive.