Lawmakers hope to ban elephants from circuses
An Animal Rights Article from


Associated Press
March 4, 2005

Ed. Note:  To us, it's obvious that elephants subjected to an unnatural life would be suffering, and as a result would at times rebel and seek their freedom.  Thus, the circuses that abuse these elephants, the communities that allow them to perform, and the public that supports them with their money and attendance, all knowingly and willfully take on the responsibility for the consequences of their actions.

HARTFORD, Conn. -- They may appear to be passive pachyderms, but performing elephants can be deadly, say some lawmakers who want to ban them from traveling shows and circuses in Connecticut.

Elephants are trained through pain, force and fear, they say. Such experiences, combined with the effects of captivity, drive some to go on rampages and trample human beings, sometimes to death, activists say.

"When they're not in their little pens, they're chained up," said Tom Rider, a former circus worker who testified Friday before the legislature's Environment Committee. "These elephants are chained and beaten every day."

Circus operators discounted the claims, arguing that they provide healthy environments and meet or exceed federal animal welfare standards.

"Our elephants live longer and healthier lives because of the care they receive," said Tom Albert, vice president of governmental relations for Feld Entertainment, which produces Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus.

The legislation before lawmakers, proposed by state Reps. Steven Fontana, D-North Haven, and Diana Urban, R-North Stonington, would prohibit the use of elephants in traveling shows, theatrical exhibitions and circuses that come to the state.

A similar bill has been proposed in Massachusetts.

Fontana said he is offering the legislation as protection for the animals and also for those who train or watch the animals perform. Between 1990 and 2003, according to the animal rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, captive elephants have killed 65 people and injured 130 others.

Last month, in Fort Wayne, Ind., a circus animal trainer loading elephants into a trailer was trampled to death after he fell. At least two of the three Asian elephants - each weighing more than 7,000 pounds - stomped on him, the coroner said.

In 1995, a New London woman was killed after a circus elephant grabbed her with its trunk and threw her to the ground in the parking lot of the New London Mall.

Ringling Bros. says there is no evidence that captive elephants are more prone to aggressive or erratic behavior than those in the wild. The circus company says trained elephants behave more predictably.

Albert said no patrons have been harmed by elephants at any of the 700 shows the three traveling Ringling Bros. circuses put on each year. A handler at Ringling Bros.' animal retirement facility in Florida was killed about 10 years ago.

"That's an awful lot of shows without having any kind of problem," Albert said.

But several animal rights activists in Connecticut told lawmakers they don't trust Ringling Bros. Some brought copies of videotapes they claim show evidence of elephant abuse.

Nancy Mathews of Fairfield said she protests the circus every time it comes to the Arena at Harbor Yard in Bridgeport. Mathews shows patrons a sharp-ended bullhook that she and other advocates accuse circus officials of using on the massive animals.

"I would like to go home today and tell my son...that finally someone who has the power to make a difference in the lives of these animals is going to do so," she told lawmakers.

If the bill becomes law and performing elephants aren't allowed in Connecticut, the Ringling Bros. circus won't be coming. Albert said the 24 elephants that regularly perform in the traveling shows are the biggest stars.

"Not bringing the elephants is not an option," he said. "We're not going to leave them at the state line or at the train yard."

Bob Commerford, owner of R.W. Commerford and Sons of Goshen, said such a law would put him out of business. He owns three elephants. Since 1964, Commerford and his family have traveled to fairs and festivals with elephants and other exotic animals, setting up an exotic zoo and offering elephant, camel and pony rides.

Commerford said he hasn't had any problems with his elephants, two Asians and an African.

"I just use common sense with it," Commerford said. "I never beat them or do other things that people say we do."

The bill awaits action by the Environment Committee.

On the Net:

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals:  

Copyright 2005, The Associated Press

To Submit a Letter to the Editor of the Stamford Advocate, email:  or fax: 203-964-2345

ARTICLE SOURCE:,0,7717044.story  

Return to Animal Rights Articles